Who Benefits From Overdiagnosis? Pharma, Device Makers, Hospitals

October 28, 2011 8:03 am 1 comment

H. Gilbert Welch. Courtesy of Dartmouth College

In recent weeks, we’ve seen the U.S.Preventive Services Task Force recommend that healthy men not have a PSA test, and read a new study suggesting that only about 3 percent to 13 percent of  women whose breast cancer was detected by a mammogram are actually helped by the test. In the case of both prostate cancer and breast cancer, test opponents argue, vastly more people are treated in ways that damage their lives than people who are helped by the tests. One study showed that for every life saved by prostate cancer treatment, 47 men are treated in ways that will probably greatly alter their sex life, not for the better. With breast cancer, a recent study published in the Archives of Internal Medicine suggests  that 1 woman per 1,000 healthy women screened over 10 years falls into the very small sample whose life is saved. Many others a treated in ways that cause pain, anxiety, and depression. The author of that study, H. Gilbert Welch, a professor of medicine and director of the Center for Medicine and the Media at the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice, recently told BU Today who, in his opinion, benefits from the kind of overdiagnosis that does so much harm: “A lot of people: pharma, device manufacturers, imaging centers, and even your local hospital. The easiest way to make money isn’t to build a better drug or device—it’s to expand the market for existing drugs and devices by expanding the indication to include more patients. Similarly, for hospitals, the easiest way to make money isn’t to deliver better care; it’s to recruit new patients—and screening is a great way to do this.”

Read more in Welch’s book, Overdiagnosed: Making People Sick in the Pursuit of Health (Beacon Press, 2011), written with coauthors Lisa Schwartz and Steven Woloshin.

1 Comment

  • Dr. David R. Jones

    I’m a chiropractor and see this everyday. We treat spinal pain and get great results and and keep many from risky surgeries(that have about a 50/50 chance of success).The insurance companies will pay for the all the drugs and very expensive surgeries, but will hardly pay for chiropractic services. Makes no sense, just wished we could work together for the best outcome for the patients.It would seem that the medical profession would get off their high horse and just consider a least invasive to most invasive approach,instead of going straight to surgeries.

Leave a Reply


Recent Posts

  • Attitude Fitness Pain Uncategorized Get Used To It: Decline Begins At 24

    Get Used To It: Decline Begins At 24

    By now, if researchers at Simon Fraser University are correct, most SportsGeezer readers have been getting a little slower and a little less sharp for decades. Yes, decades. In fact, based on an analysis of digital performance records of 3,305 StarCraft 2 players aged 16 to 44, researchers have concluded that our cognitive performance starts going downhill at age 24. The good news for those who are well past 24? “Older players, though slower, seem to compensate by employing simpler […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Gear One-Two Punch For Body Fat: Green Tea + Exercise

    One-Two Punch For Body Fat: Green Tea + Exercise

    Exercise is a great way to lose weight, but exercise combined with green tea is even greater. A Penn State news release reports that researchers at the school found that high-fat-fed mice that exercised regularly and ingested green tea extract showed an average body mass reduction of 27.1 percent and an average abdominal fat mass reduction of 36.6 percent in just 16 weeks. Is that a lot? Well, mice that ingested green tea extract but did not exercise or those […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Exercises To Prevent ACL Tears

    Exercises To Prevent ACL Tears

    Writing in the New York Times, Gretchen Reynolds claims that proper warm-up exercises have been shown to reduce ACL tears by 50 percent. What exercises? Well, for starters, there are the exercises in the video below.

    Read more →
  • Attitude Pain Anger Multiplies Heart Attack Risk By Five

    Anger Multiplies Heart Attack Risk By Five

    Forget “Don’t get angry, get even.” Try “Don’t get angry and spare yourself a heart attack.” The New York Times reports on research conducted at Harvard Medical School suggesting that in the two hours after an outburst of anger, the risk of angina and heart attack increases by nearly five times, while the risk of ischemic stroke and cardiac arrhythmia increases by more than three times. The researchers got there by combining data from nine studies of anger outbursts among […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Extreme Sports = Extremely High Rate of Head Injuries

    Extreme Sports = Extremely High Rate of Head Injuries

    Mountain biking, snowboarding, surfing, motocross, snowmobiling, downhill skiing and skateboarding are fun, largely because they can be wickedawesomefast. They are also, according to research conducted at the department of orthopaedic surgery at Western Michigan University School of Medicine, wickedawesomedangerous. In fact, they are sufficiently wickedawesomedangerous to have caused 4 million injuries since 2000, and to now cause more than 40,000 head and neck injuries a year. HealthDay reports on the Michigan conclusions, which are based on information collected by the […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Glucosamine Does Nothing For Knee Pain

    Glucosamine Does Nothing For Knee Pain

    Yes, it’s true: Millions of people pay large amounts of money for something that does absolutely nothing. Glucosamine, alleged to relieve pain and slow damage in arthritic joints, does neither, at least in knee joints, according to a study published in the journal Arthritis & Rheumatology.  HealthDay reports that researchers, working with 200 people with mild to moderate pain in one or both knees, randomly selected some to drink 1,500 milligrams a day of glucosamine and some to get a […]

    Read more →
  • Attitude Pain Worried About Senior Moments? Forget About Them

    Worried About Senior Moments? Forget About Them

    Are you worried that your forgetful senior moments are an indicator of things to come? Forget about it. That’s the advice from researchers at the Institute of Primary Medical Care in Kiel, Germany, where a recent three-year-long study of people with mild cognitive impairment found that 42 percent returned to normal mental function, 36 percent retained their mild impairment and only 22 percent developed dementia.  HealthDay reports that the study found that 21 percent of participants fluctuated between mild cognitive impairment […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Sex Another Confusing Study About Prostate Cancer Treatment

    Another Confusing Study About Prostate Cancer Treatment

    Should men have a PSA test? And if the test turns of up some cancerous cells, should they treat it? One year after many cancer experts advised against both actions, a Swedish study involving 695 men diagnosed with prostate cancer in the 1980s and 1990s has shown that those who had a localized tumor removed in a radical prostatectomy were 44 percent less likely to die of the disease. The Los Angeles Times reports on the study, which appears in Thursday’s […]

    Read more →