Who Benefits From Overdiagnosis? Pharma, Device Makers, Hospitals

October 28, 2011 8:03 am 1 comment

H. Gilbert Welch. Courtesy of Dartmouth College

In recent weeks, we’ve seen the U.S.Preventive Services Task Force recommend that healthy men not have a PSA test, and read a new study suggesting that only about 3 percent to 13 percent of  women whose breast cancer was detected by a mammogram are actually helped by the test. In the case of both prostate cancer and breast cancer, test opponents argue, vastly more people are treated in ways that damage their lives than people who are helped by the tests. One study showed that for every life saved by prostate cancer treatment, 47 men are treated in ways that will probably greatly alter their sex life, not for the better. With breast cancer, a recent study published in the Archives of Internal Medicine suggests  that 1 woman per 1,000 healthy women screened over 10 years falls into the very small sample whose life is saved. Many others a treated in ways that cause pain, anxiety, and depression. The author of that study, H. Gilbert Welch, a professor of medicine and director of the Center for Medicine and the Media at the Dartmouth Institute for Health Policy and Clinical Practice, recently told BU Today who, in his opinion, benefits from the kind of overdiagnosis that does so much harm: “A lot of people: pharma, device manufacturers, imaging centers, and even your local hospital. The easiest way to make money isn’t to build a better drug or device—it’s to expand the market for existing drugs and devices by expanding the indication to include more patients. Similarly, for hospitals, the easiest way to make money isn’t to deliver better care; it’s to recruit new patients—and screening is a great way to do this.”

Read more in Welch’s book, Overdiagnosed: Making People Sick in the Pursuit of Health (Beacon Press, 2011), written with coauthors Lisa Schwartz and Steven Woloshin.

1 Comment

  • Dr. David R. Jones

    I’m a chiropractor and see this everyday. We treat spinal pain and get great results and and keep many from risky surgeries(that have about a 50/50 chance of success).The insurance companies will pay for the all the drugs and very expensive surgeries, but will hardly pay for chiropractic services. Makes no sense, just wished we could work together for the best outcome for the patients.It would seem that the medical profession would get off their high horse and just consider a least invasive to most invasive approach,instead of going straight to surgeries.

Leave a Reply


Recent Posts

  • Pain What Those Crackly Knee Sounds Really Mean

    What Those Crackly Knee Sounds Really Mean

    What do those crackly noises made by your knees really mean? Researchers at Georgia Tech who have devised a way to record the sounds of healthy and unhealthy knees have this answer: it depends. First, they say, all knees make crackly sounds, even if you can’t hear them. Healthy knees produce a consistent pattern of sounds, while damaged knees are more erratic noisemakers. So far, the researchers aren’t diagnosing specific problems with sound, but they can use their tools to […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Uncategorized How To Stay (Relatively) Safe From Ticks

    How To Stay (Relatively) Safe From Ticks

    From Stephen Wikel, professor emeritus of medical sciences at Quinnipiac University’s Frank H. Netter M.D. School of Medicine, comes this advice, via HealthDay, about how to stay safe from ticks: Protect your ankles. Wear long pants tucked into high socks when doing yard work. Wrap duct tape — sticky-side out — around where the pants and socks meet so that crawling ticks get stuck on the tape. Dress properly. Use clothing, tents and other gear treated with repellent, such as permethrin. […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Pain Dinner By Candlelight May Keep You Thin

    Dinner By Candlelight May Keep You Thin

    It could be true: researchers at Northwestern University have learned that insulin was unable to quickly bring glucose levels back to a normal level following a meal with bright light exposure in the evening. Yes, that does matter, because the body’s inability to adequately move glucose out of the bloodstream, can, over time, help put the pounds on. A Northwestern new release reports that previous research by Northwestern scientists showed that people who received the majority of their bright light in […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Pain Exercise May Reduce Risk Of 13 Cancers

    Exercise May Reduce Risk Of 13 Cancers

    And now, thirteen ways of looking at exercise: Researchers at the University of North Carolina’s school of public health are convinced that working out just a couple of times a week can cut the risk of 13 types of cancer, including cancer of the breast, colon, lung, as well as leukemia, myeloma and cancers of the esophagus, liver, kidney, stomach, endometrium, rectum, bladder, and head and neck. Yikes!  Science Daily reports on the research, which looked at 1.4 million people, and […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Gear Barefoot Running Is Good For Your Brain

    Barefoot Running Is Good For Your Brain

    Barefoot running, all the rage a few years ago, may boost more than cardio fitness. A new study by researchers at the University of North Florida suggests that it can also boost your memory. Men’s Fitness reports on the research, for which 72 participants between 18 and 44 were recruited to run either barefoot or with running shoes at a comfortable,  pace for roughly 16 minutes on a track. In order to simulate the way barefoot runners aim their feet to […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Sex Testosterone Won’t Increase Risk Of Aggressive Prostate Cancer

    Testosterone Won’t Increase Risk Of Aggressive Prostate Cancer

    For years, experts have debated the likelihood that testosterone therapy will increase the risk of aggressive prostate cancer. That’s because, as Science Daily points out, standard therapy for advanced prostate cancer decreased tumor growth with drugs that drastically reduce rather than increase male hormones. Now come researchers from the NYU Langone Medical Center and its Laura and Isaac Perlmutter Cancer Center, who are convinced that the best thing men can do is keep testosterone levels balanced and within a normal range. […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Heartburn Drugs May Damage Kidneys

    Heartburn Drugs May Damage Kidneys

    Prevacid, Prilosec, Nexium and Protonix are the names of four popular brands for proton pump inhibitors (PPIs), drugs that decrease gastric acid production and are sold to treat heartburn, which they do fairly well. Unfortunately, according to a study by researchers at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis and Veterans Affairs St. Louis Health Care System, they can also lead to serious kidney damage. A Wash U news release reports that researchers at the school examined national VA […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Medical Errors Are Third Leading Cause of Death

    Medical Errors Are Third Leading Cause of Death

    Thinking about going under the knife? Think about this: Researchers at Johns Hopkins who studied eight years of medical death rates believe that medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the United States. A Johns Hopkins news release reports that researchers put the number of people killed by errors somewhere north of 250,000. Why did it take so long to figure that out? Because, says says Martin Makary, professor of surgery at the Johns Hopkins University School of […]

    Read more →