Mammograms Save Few Lives, Treatment Harms Many

October 25, 2011 7:40 am 3 comments

As goes PSA testing for prostate cancer, so goes mammography for breast cancer. A new study published in the Archives of Internal Medicine suggests that the great majority women who find breast cancer as a result of regular screening have not had their lives saved by the test. But, as Tara Parker-Pope reports in the New York Times Well column, many have had their lives diminished by unnecessary treatment. Two Dartmouth researchers, Dr. H. Gilbert Welch and Brittney A. Frankel, estimated a woman’s 10-year risk of developing breast cancer and her 20-year risk of death, factoring in the added value of early detection based on data from various mammography screening trials as well as the benefits of improvements in treatment. Among the 60 percent of women with breast cancer who detected the disease by screening, only about 3 percent to 13 percent of them were actually helped by the test. It’s true: the researchers believe that of the 138,000 women found to have breast cancer each year as a result of mammography screening, 120,000 to 134,000 are not helped by the test. That’s because of the truly deadly cancers that are caught by screening, only a small fraction are caught at the moment when treatment can help. Parker-Pope reports that clinical trial data suggests that 1 woman per 1,000 healthy women screened over 10 years falls into this category, although experts say that number is probably even smaller today because of advances in breast cancer treatments. Read more in the New York Times.

3 Comments

  • Not quite sure where the hell they came up with this. Having a Mammogram have saved my wife’s life on two occasions!!!

    • Trent R. Royer

      It’s called statistical data, and the information has been available for a decade now. Your wife may have been diagnosed with cancer after a screening, but it is highly, highly unlikely that her life was saved as a result of it. Women have been brainwashed into believing mammograms are the be all and end all, when in reality, they do more harm overall than good. Men didn’t protest when PSA screening was appropriately halted and it is important for women to educate themselves about what they are really getting themselves into when they agree to asymptomatic cancer screenings.

  • Let me guess another study by the government! So this is what universal helth care is all about?

Leave a Reply


Recent Posts

  • Fitness Pain Women's Health Weekly Weigh-Ins Help Us Lose Weight

    Weekly Weigh-Ins Help Us Lose Weight

    When can you stop weighing yourself? Whenever you want to, but if you really want to keep losing weight, it’s best to weigh-in at least once a week. That’s the conclusion of researchers at Cornell University’s Food and Brand Lab, where scientists analyzed 2,838 weight measurements (up to a years’ worth of weigh-ins) from 40 overweight people who were trying to lose weight.  A Cornell news release reports that the researchers found that the more frequently people weighed in, the more […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Pain Where Exactly Does The Fat Go?

    Where Exactly Does The Fat Go?

    When you lose weight, where does the fat go? Don’t ask your doctor: new research at the University of New South Wales suggests that more than 50 percent of doctors think it’s converted to energy. Wrong. The correct answer is into the air, breathed out as carbon dioxide. A UNSW news release reports that losing 10 kilograms (22 pounds) of fat requires 29 kilograms (64 pounds) of oxygen to be inhaled and that this metabolic process produces 28 kilograms (62 pounds) […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Fitness Pain Irregular Heartbeat Treatment Improved By Exercise, Diet

    Irregular Heartbeat Treatment Improved By Exercise, Diet

    Atrial fibrillation–doctors know it as AF,  you know it a disturbing irregular heartbeat–can be bad for your health. It is usually remedied with a procedure called catheter ablation, in which electricity is used to burn the tissue around the problem area. Strange, but it works, somewhat. Now comes a study from researchers at the University of Adelaide suggesting a way to greatly improve the likelihood that it will continue to work. A U of Adelaide news release reports that researchers at […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Pain Women's Health For Women, Daily Aspirin Does More Harm Than Good

    For Women, Daily Aspirin Does More Harm Than Good

    Much has been written, yes, even on SportsGeezer, about the benefits of taking a low-dose of aspirin each day. Now comes some other news about aspirin, and it’s not so rosy. HealthDay reports on research conducted at Harvard Medical School that analyzed the results of a clinical trial of nearly 28,000 women who were largely healthy and relatively young — about 55 years old, on average at the start of the study, and were randomly assigned to take low-dose (100 mg) aspirin or […]

    Read more →
  • Attitude Fitness Pain Running Cuts Risk Of Death From Alzheimer’s

    Running Cuts Risk Of Death From Alzheimer’s

    It’s true that this study didn’t find an association between running and getting Alzheimer’s, but that’s because the researchers didn’t look for one. What they did look for was an association between running and death from Alzheimer’s, and they found a big one: people who ran more than 15.3 miles a week had a 40 percent risk reduction in death from Alzheimer’s, and those who ran between 7.7 and 15.3 miles had a 25 percent risk reduction. Wait, there’s more: […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Pain Another Thing That Garlic May Ward Off: Prostate Cancer

    Another Thing That Garlic May Ward Off: Prostate Cancer

    Yes, in addition to its folkloric power to deter evil spirits, garlic may slow the spread of some cancers, including prostate, melanoma, and some types of leukemia, all of which weaken the body by over-activating the natural immune system. A University of Copenhagen news release reports that researchers at the school have found that selenium, which is found in garlic and broccoli, slows down the immune over-response, which may improve cancer treatment. How? It’s complicated, but here we go: The immune system […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Pain Women's Health Heavy Drinker Or Alcoholic? That Is The Question

    Heavy Drinker Or Alcoholic? That Is The Question

    Is this good news? The New York Times reports that a new study of results from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health suggests that nine out of 10 people who drink too much are not addicts, and can change their behavior with sufficient prompting. It could be good news, except the Times also reports that excessive drinking, the kind practiced by non-alcoholics as well as alcoholics, results in 88,000 deaths a year, from causes that include alcohol poisoning and […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Fitness Pain Walnuts Slow Prostate Cancer

    Walnuts Slow Prostate Cancer

    Yes, it appears to be true: walnuts slow the growth of prostate cancer, at least in mice. A UC Davis news release reports that researchers at the school had found, in a previous study, that walnuts reduced prostate tumor size in mice, but the researchers weren’t sure which parts of the nuts generated these benefits. This time around, the researchers used a mixture of fats with virtually the same fatty acid content as walnuts as their control diet. Mice were […]

    Read more →