Study Says Claims Of Fitness Products Mostly Smoke

July 24, 2012 9:20 am 1 comment

Ever wonder how close to reality come the advertising claims of fitness products? Dr. Matthew Thompson, a senior clinical scientist at the University of Oxford, decided to find out. His conclusion: not so much. Nicholas Bakalar, writing in the New York Times, reports that Thompson and his colleagues examined advertising for sports drinks, oral supplements, footwear, clothing and devices like wrist bands and compression stockings in 100 general–interest magazines and the top 10 sports and fitness magazines, as well as websites, in Britain and the United States. The researchers stopped short of including bodybuilding magazines and advertisements for weight loss, skin or beauty products, and equipment like bicycles and exercise machines. The researchers tried hard to find studies backing up the claims, and even wrote to 42 companies, 27 of which responded. Their scholarly conclusion: There is a striking lack of evidence to support the vast majority of sports-related products that make claims related to enhanced performance or recovery, including drinks, supplements and footwear. Half of all websites for these products provided no evidence for their claims, and of those that do, half of the evidence is not suitable for critical appraisal. No systematic reviews were found, and overall, the evidence base was judged to be at high risk of bias. Half of the trials were not randomised, and only 7% reported adequate allocation concealment. We found only three trials that were reported with sufficient details to be judged high quality and free from bias. Download the study here.  Read more in the New York Times.

1 Comment

  • When I exercise, one to two hours a day I sweat. Along with the water I lose electrolytes. This almost always results in cramps if I hydrate with water alone. I find if I put electrolytes in the water, primarily table salt I reduce the number and severity of the cramps. Sports drinks actually help, but not really as effective as sodium chloride, half a teaspoon in 8 oz of water. None the less I will use sports drinks in addition to salted water. I find plane water does not help with cramps from dehydration and electrolyte loss from intensive exercise.

Leave a Reply


Recent Posts

  • Eating Well Pain Women's Health Heavy Drinker Or Alcoholic? That Is The Question

    Heavy Drinker Or Alcoholic? That Is The Question

    Is this good news? The New York Times reports that a new study of results from the National Survey on Drug Use and Health suggests that nine out of 10 people who drink too much are not addicts, and can change their behavior with sufficient prompting. It could be good news, except the Times also reports that excessive drinking, the kind practiced by non-alcoholics as well as alcoholics, results in 88,000 deaths a year, from causes that include alcohol poisoning and […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Fitness Pain Walnuts Slow Prostate Cancer

    Walnuts Slow Prostate Cancer

    Yes, it appears to be true: walnuts slow the growth of prostate cancer, at least in mice. A UC Davis news release reports that researchers at the school had found, in a previous study, that walnuts reduced prostate tumor size in mice, but the researchers weren’t sure which parts of the nuts generated these benefits. This time around, the researchers used a mixture of fats with virtually the same fatty acid content as walnuts as their control diet. Mice were […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Gear

    Ski Season Is Just Around The Corner. Are You Ready?

    It’s true that many midwesterners are less than thrilled with this week’s blast of winter weather, but skiers elsewhere are getting psyched. But wait, there’s something else: getting in shape. A quick review of the forest of websites offering get-into-ski-shape advice reveals general agreement on the benefits of two exercises: squats and lunges. The rest, my friends, is chatter. Livestrong.com describes squats as “the cornerstone” of your skiing workout,” and recommends that you compound the gain (and pain) by doing […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Why Scratching An Itch Makes It Worse

    Why Scratching An Itch Makes It Worse

    No, it doesn’t make sense. Why would scratching an itch make it itch even more? It’s like eating food making you more hungry. Researchers at Washington University in St. Louis thought so too, so they did some scratching experiments–with mice, of course, not humans, to find out why. Why? It’s about itch signals and pain signals and brain chemicals jumping tracks.  A Wash U news story reports that the researchers found that scratching creates a mild amount of pain in the skin, which […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Sex Another Bad Way To Treat Low-Grade Prostate Cancer

    Another Bad Way To Treat Low-Grade Prostate Cancer

    It’s called androgen deprivation therapy, ADT for short, and it works like this: drugs (and there are several that can be used) are administered, often by injection, to suppress testosterone production, because lowering testosterone levels has been shown slow the growth of prostate cancer cells. But wait. Now, from researchers at Tulane University, comes a study showing that for men with low-grade, slow-growing disease, ADT can do more harm than good. There are two reasons for that: one, low-grade prostate […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Pain The New York Times’ Seven-Minute Workout

    The New York Times’ Seven-Minute Workout

    No, you don’t need exotic machineries; you don’t even need a gym. Here’s what you need: a chair, a wall, and gravity, which is widely available at no cost. Wait, you also need seven minutes. That’s how long it takes, according to New York Times Health columnist Gretchen Reynolds, to stay is shape, but you have to be willing to really put out during those seven minutes. Writing in the Times, Reynolds gives us 12 exercises recommended by Chris Jordan, the […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Fitness Pain How To Lose Weight: Stay Cold and Hungry

    How To Lose Weight: Stay Cold and Hungry

    There are some very pleasant ways to keep the weight off–playing tennis or swimming–and then there are two much less pleasant conditions that researchers at Yale believe could do the same thing, by turning white fat (bad) into brown fat (good.) Cold and hunger. Yes, staying cold and hungry could keep us thin. Maybe.  Yale News reports that researchers at the Yale School of Medicine have uncovered a molecular process in the brain known to control eating that transforms white fat into brown […]

    Read more →
  • Attitude Pain Computer Brain Games Are For Losers

    Computer Brain Games Are For Losers

    Brain games, the computer based mental challenges that promise to boost the brain power of older adults, are an excellent way to waste time, but they do almost nothing to make us smarter. That’s the opinion of 69 scholars, including many cognitive psychologists and neuroscientists from around the world. A Stanford University news release reports that the scholars, who have jointly issued a statement expressing their skepticism, say that while people who play computer brain games may improve their scores on […]

    Read more →