Glucosamine, Chondroitin Are Useless for Hip and Knee Arthritis

September 17, 2010 7:28 am 21 comments

The market for arthritis drugs is a powerful (46 million people) incentive to sell drug and supplements, and the pain of arthritris is a powerful incentive to take drugs and supplements. Now comes a large and persuasive study, actually a careful analysis of ten other studies involving nearly 4,000 people, that suggests that two of the most popular supplements, glucosamine and chondroitin, do nothing to relieve arthritis pain in knees and hips. Web MD reports that the government-funded Glucosamine/chondroitin Arthritis Intervention Trial (GAIT)  showed that overall, the  two supplements did not improve hip or knee osteoarthritis (OA) pain. A follow-up arm of this study showed that they did not do any better than placebo in slowing loss of cartilage that occurs in osteoarthritis of the knee. OA is the wear-and-tear form of arthritis, and affects more than 20 million people. WebMD reports that a smaller subset of GAIT participants with moderate-to-severe OA pain, did get some relief with the combined supplements.

Read more from Web MD.

21 Comments

  • I disagree:
    I take Glucosamine and it works for me

  • I agree with George.

  • You are all idiots.

  • Speaking as an RN—there is an effect called the “placebo effect”, where if a person STRONGLY believes that x, y, or z will help him or cure him, it does in fact have a benecial result.
    However, when “double blind” tests are run by objective scientists or MD’s, no real long term physical change has taken place. In a double blind test, the drug or vitamin or herb is tested on a group of volunteers with the condition being studied. Neither the volunteers NOR the testers know which group is getting the “real” thing and which is getting the placebo or what used to be called “sugar water”.
    Sometimes the results of the test are so outstandingly positive the test is called off so everyone who needs that particular drug etc can have it/ vice versa, it can be called off early if the great majority have NO benefit.
    So, what they are saying here is that Glucosamine/Chondroitin MAY help some people feel better but it is not changing your joint damage.

  • I used them for years now I have 2 knees replace ED.

  • Bill said! Look at what you just read,and that will explain it all. Look!Government funded trial!! That said it! End of subject!!Have a Nice Day!

  • nevilles4@att.net

    All I know is that 15 years ago, I was very close to having to take disability retirement because of my arthritis. I started taking Glucosamine/Chondroitin twice daily. I took normal retirement 2 months ago. I’ll always beleive that it worked for me, my wife & my brother-in-law.

  • they work for me, better then vioxx, if of course you dont believe in it, or disagree, then dont use it,george is right tom is an idiot or yuppie which is worse

  • I agree, after spending way too much $ waiting years for replacements! Even the quasi-cartiledge injections @ $300/set only lasted 5-6 weeks. Nothing works like Zimmer parts.

  • byron D… I agree with Bill C. and will someone in these Ynited States please step up and say – I was one one who participated in that “gov funded ” study.

  • byron D… I agree with Bill C. and will someone in these Ynited States please step up and say – I was one one who participated in that “gov funded ” study.

  • Cartilage like bone is building back up breaking down at the same time. Glocosamine and chondroitin are, at least in theory, raw materials for building carilage. If their use could tilt the balance toward cartilage construction ever so slightly they would be useful supplements. None of the current research addresses this point(CT and MRI measurements would not be sensitive enough) so studies that attempt to characterize G and C as pain killers are beside the point.

  • I agree with George,
    I was in a great deal of pain in my knees . A friend recomended Glucosamine and I was desperate for anything that would relieve the pain so I tried it for 2- month’s 1- pill a day and nothing happened? so I stopped and I thought it was a bunch of hype.Then I was talking to a woman friend at a party and she said that she did not know how she would live with the pain in her hands if she did not have glucosamine to take? I told her I took it for 2-months and it did not do a thing for me! She then asked me how much I had been taking and I told her 1-tablet per day and she replied no wonder it did not work for you you are a big guy 240-lbs. you should at least be taking 2- tabs a day or more? I asked her how many she takes per day and she replied 5-tabs and she is around 138-lbs.That was in 2005 and I have continued with 2-tabs everyday. Now , I do not know what I would do if I could not take or use Glucosamine. DO not get me wrong. I sometimes still do have a pain here or there but it is not the constant pain that I was enduring and suffering before I started taking the Glucosamine.I think that if it works for you take it and if it does not stop but don’t judge the people who it seems to be working for in a negative way as they are only doing the best they can.
    Goodluck to all, Tom

  • I don’t know if it is effective or not in everyone, but it worked for me. I had scopes in both knees. Pain returned and I was ready for replacements. Took injections which did help. Took Cosamine religiously. No pain in two years. Can walk fine. I would agree it doesn’t work for everyone, but it is not my imagination that the pain is gone.

  • Here is THE telling statement of this whole inquiry:
    QUOTE:
    The market for arthritis drugs is a powerful (46 million people)
    THE MARKET IS BIG, and natural supplements take a BIG CHUNK out of the revenue stream that the big pharmas would LIKE to maintain.
    So … the (dis)information wars (based upon ‘studies’) continue……

  • I would like to tell my story. I was building a two story house and visiting the project I realize my legs started hurting when I was climbing the stairs to the second floor. A nurse friend of mine recommended to me to take the pills G&C and I did. The pain went away and I am still taking two a day. My dog, a 16 years old dalmata, started having problems when walking and I found at the pet supermarket a seniors dog food with this medicine and now he runs without problems. For me and my dog definitely worked.
    Mafalda

  • My knees hurt me daily and I thought I’d read this and get some help! LOL, I am in the same boat now as when I started.
    Truthbknown

  • after 15 years of pain swelling and clicing as i walked up stairs. i went to the campell clinic were they told me to take Glucosamine/Chondroitin 3 pills a day its been 4 years no bone on bone clic, no swelling no pain. you can believe what you want. we all say ya or na but unless you try it you wont know

  • I think it may be the doseage that makes the difference. Single pill did not wokr for me either but when I switched to WELLESSE Joint Movenment Glucosamine ( a liquid that contains 2000 mg of glucosamine ,1200 mg. chondroitin, 500 mg. MSM and take 2 tablespoons aday.. and iot works very well. EASIER TO TAKE AND TASTE NOT BAD. My 2 cents and I give 1/2 tablespoon to the dog in her water and it works for her too and she is 16 yrs old… much improved…

  • I’ll have to tell my golden retriever with severe hip displasia that all the times he’s been been unable to walk without the glucosamine and able to walk with it, he’s been taking a placebo, and the pill didn’t really help him.

  • Are you planning on any replacement?

Leave a Reply


Recent Posts

  • Attitude Fitness Pain Uncategorized Get Used To It: Decline Begins At 24

    Get Used To It: Decline Begins At 24

    By now, if researchers at Simon Fraser University are correct, most SportsGeezer readers have been getting a little slower and a little less sharp for decades. Yes, decades. In fact, based on an analysis of digital performance records of 3,305 StarCraft 2 players aged 16 to 44, researchers have concluded that our cognitive performance starts going downhill at age 24. The good news for those who are well past 24? “Older players, though slower, seem to compensate by employing simpler […]

    Read more →
  • Eating Well Gear One-Two Punch For Body Fat: Green Tea + Exercise

    One-Two Punch For Body Fat: Green Tea + Exercise

    Exercise is a great way to lose weight, but exercise combined with green tea is even greater. A Penn State news release reports that researchers at the school found that high-fat-fed mice that exercised regularly and ingested green tea extract showed an average body mass reduction of 27.1 percent and an average abdominal fat mass reduction of 36.6 percent in just 16 weeks. Is that a lot? Well, mice that ingested green tea extract but did not exercise or those […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Exercises To Prevent ACL Tears

    Exercises To Prevent ACL Tears

    Writing in the New York Times, Gretchen Reynolds claims that proper warm-up exercises have been shown to reduce ACL tears by 50 percent. What exercises? Well, for starters, there are the exercises in the video below.

    Read more →
  • Attitude Pain Anger Multiplies Heart Attack Risk By Five

    Anger Multiplies Heart Attack Risk By Five

    Forget “Don’t get angry, get even.” Try “Don’t get angry and spare yourself a heart attack.” The New York Times reports on research conducted at Harvard Medical School suggesting that in the two hours after an outburst of anger, the risk of angina and heart attack increases by nearly five times, while the risk of ischemic stroke and cardiac arrhythmia increases by more than three times. The researchers got there by combining data from nine studies of anger outbursts among […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Extreme Sports = Extremely High Rate of Head Injuries

    Extreme Sports = Extremely High Rate of Head Injuries

    Mountain biking, snowboarding, surfing, motocross, snowmobiling, downhill skiing and skateboarding are fun, largely because they can be wickedawesomefast. They are also, according to research conducted at the department of orthopaedic surgery at Western Michigan University School of Medicine, wickedawesomedangerous. In fact, they are sufficiently wickedawesomedangerous to have caused 4 million injuries since 2000, and to now cause more than 40,000 head and neck injuries a year. HealthDay reports on the Michigan conclusions, which are based on information collected by the […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Glucosamine Does Nothing For Knee Pain

    Glucosamine Does Nothing For Knee Pain

    Yes, it’s true: Millions of people pay large amounts of money for something that does absolutely nothing. Glucosamine, alleged to relieve pain and slow damage in arthritic joints, does neither, at least in knee joints, according to a study published in the journal Arthritis & Rheumatology.  HealthDay reports that researchers, working with 200 people with mild to moderate pain in one or both knees, randomly selected some to drink 1,500 milligrams a day of glucosamine and some to get a […]

    Read more →
  • Attitude Pain Worried About Senior Moments? Forget About Them

    Worried About Senior Moments? Forget About Them

    Are you worried that your forgetful senior moments are an indicator of things to come? Forget about it. That’s the advice from researchers at the Institute of Primary Medical Care in Kiel, Germany, where a recent three-year-long study of people with mild cognitive impairment found that 42 percent returned to normal mental function, 36 percent retained their mild impairment and only 22 percent developed dementia.  HealthDay reports that the study found that 21 percent of participants fluctuated between mild cognitive impairment […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Sex Another Confusing Study About Prostate Cancer Treatment

    Another Confusing Study About Prostate Cancer Treatment

    Should men have a PSA test? And if the test turns of up some cancerous cells, should they treat it? One year after many cancer experts advised against both actions, a Swedish study involving 695 men diagnosed with prostate cancer in the 1980s and 1990s has shown that those who had a localized tumor removed in a radical prostatectomy were 44 percent less likely to die of the disease. The Los Angeles Times reports on the study, which appears in Thursday’s […]

    Read more →