We Are Fat Because We Are Hungry, And Here’s Why

May 17, 2014 8:06 am 2 comments

In a long and well-read (over 200 comments) piece in the New York Times76444-354x233-Bagel, two obesity researchers explain why we are fat– because we eat too much; why we eat too much–because we are always hungry; and why we are always hungry–because we eat the wrong foods. By wrong foods, they mean processed foods and high carbohydrate foods. David S. Ludwig, director of the New Balance Foundation Obesity Prevention Center at Boston Children’s Hospital and a professor of pediatrics at Harvard Medical School and Mark I. Friedman, vice president of research at the Nutrition Science Initiative don’t say anything that hasn’t been said before, but they say it persuasively, because they back it up evidence, including two studies conducted by Ludwig. In one, the Times reports, Ludwig examined 21 overweight and obese young adults after they had lost 10 to 15 percent of their body weight, on diets ranging from low fat to low carbohydrate. Despite consuming the same number of calories on each diet, subjects burned about 325 more calories per day on the low carbohydrate than on the low fat diet — amounting to the energy expended in an hour of moderately intense physical activity. In another, Ludwig found that rats fed a diet with rapidly digesting (called high “glycemic index”) carbohydrate gained 71 percent more fat than their counterparts, who ate more calories over all, though in the form of slowly digesting carbohydrate. Here’s the bottom line:  “With reduced consumption of refined grains, concentrated sugar and potato products and a few other sensible lifestyle choices, our internal body weight control system should be able to do the rest. Eventually, we could bring the body weight set point back to pre-epidemic levels. Addressing the underlying biological drive to overeat may make for a far more practical and effective solution to obesity than counting calories.” Read more in the New York Times.

2 Comments

  • Add to that dysfunctional fat cells as evidenced by the “gut” which is indicative of shortening telomeres and is also evidence of dysfunctional cells in other body tissues. This is what we arrive at. Total calories is at issue especially for those who have this issue earlier in life then becomes exacerbated with the lack of effective cells otherwise we would not become ravenously hungry until the energy stores were closer to depletion. The addictive food additives(flavor enhancers magnify the problem dramatically.

  • Sugar and high fructose corn syrup among others more addictive than cocaine. Virtually all of us alive now are so because of the desire for high energy foods even today when foods are quite plentiful, someone without this trait would probably die of starvation specifically for lack of calories-energy as most other foods require more net energy to process than they provide. Those without the sweet tooth, including high calorie fats/carbohydrates probably succumbed during food shortages-famines.

Leave a Reply


Recent Posts

  • Fitness Pain For Boomers, Meniscus Repair No Better Than No Repair

    For Boomers, Meniscus Repair No Better Than No Repair

    Looking for the best surgeon to repair a torn meniscus? Four million people do that every year. Yet now comes research from McMaster University that suggests they should stop looking and start physical therapy. A McMaster news release reports that researchers at the school reviewed seven studies involving 805 patients (average age 56) that looked at the success of surgical repairs of partial meniscus tears. What did they find? The envelope please…four of the studies found no short-term pain relief in the […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Pain More Exercise = More Tolerance For Pain

    More Exercise = More Tolerance For Pain

    It’s not news, as Gretchen Reynolds writes in the New York Times, that our tolerance for pain increases when we exercise–and she means at the time we exercise. Everyone knows that. But it is news, as she reports, that exercise has been shown to increase our tolerance for pain in the long term. Reynolds directs our attention to a study done at University of New South Wales and Neuroscience Research Australia and published in Medicine & Science in Sports & […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Pain Running For Fitness: Stop At 30 Miles Per Week

    Running For Fitness: Stop At 30 Miles Per Week

    OK, the first thing to consider is that this study was done with heart-attack survivors. The second thing to know is there are plenty of studies that contradict its findings. What ev, here we go. Researchers at the Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory and at Hartford Hospital studied the relationship between exercise and cardiovascular disease-related deaths in about 2,400 physically active heart-attack survivors, using the National Walkers’ and Runners’ Health Studies databases. What did they find? A reduction of cardiovascular events of up to […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Women's Health How To Brush Your Teeth: Nobody Really Knows

    How To Brush Your Teeth: Nobody Really Knows

    Looking for some advice on how to brush your teeth? The more people you ask, the more different answers you are likely to get. That’s what researchers at University College in London learned when they looked at the brushing advice given by dental associations across ten countries, toothpaste and toothbrush companies and in dental textbooks. The research revealed what is described as “no clear consensus between the various sources, and a worrying lack of agreement between advice from dental associations […]

    Read more →
  • Gear How To Buy Running Shoes: An Authoritative Guide

    How To Buy Running Shoes: An Authoritative Guide

    How hard is it to buy running shoes? Slightly less hard than buying craft beer is these days, but only slightly. Fortunately, runners have the American College of Sports Medicine to turn to for advice, lots of advice. Look, here’s some now: The college recommends that a running shoe have “minimal heel-to-toe drop: This drop is the difference in the thickness of the heel cushion to the thickness in the forefoot cushion area. Shoes with no drop or a small […]

    Read more →
  • Fitness Pain Sex Cycling May Increase Prostate Cancer Risk. Or Not.

    Cycling May Increase Prostate Cancer Risk. Or Not.

    That’s right. Cycling may increase the risk of prostate cancer. Or, it may not. How helpful is that knowledge, which comes from a study at University College in London, where researchers took a hard look at the cycling habits and health of more than 5,000 male cyclists? The good news: the study appeared to disprove the suggestions of some research that cycling increases the risk of impotence and infertility. The possibly bad news: the men who biked the most, more […]

    Read more →
  • Pain Shin Splints. Funny Name, But Not Fun

    Shin Splints. Funny Name, But Not Fun

    Shin splints sound like the kind of thing that might be amusing, at least until you learn that their technical name is medial tibial stress syndrome. Ouch! That hurts, and shin splints can hurt for a long time, up to six months, according to this piece in the Los Angeles Times.  The Times tell us that the “stress” in “medial tibial stress syndrome” is exerted on the soft tissue surrounding the tibia, and that tissue becomes inflamed. What causes them? […]

    Read more →
  • Attitude Pain Men Would Rather Hurt Themselves Than Be Alone With Their Thoughts

    Men Would Rather Hurt Themselves Than Be Alone With Their Thoughts

    Apparently, it really does hurt to think. And researchers at the University of Virginia and Harvard have demonstrated just how much it can hurt, in a series of experiments that asked people to sit alone with their thoughts. A UVA news release reports that the researchers found that study participants did not enjoy spending even brief periods of time alone in a room with nothing to do but think, ponder or daydream. Most preferred listening to music or using a […]

    Read more →